At the end of the day it's surely best going with what you like. Yes, it's a big outlay but a good awning will last you for years and it's a godsend, especially on those wet and windy days.
Our conventional shaped awning must be 15 years old by now but it still holds its shape and stands up well to the weather and I daresay the new shape ones will too.
The big problem we find with a heavy fabric awning is that although they are very cosy in bad weather they are a nightmare to dry out and are very heavy and bulky to carry, especially when wet.
We are seriously considering a lightweight "drive away" awning which will probably be very easy to tour with but if we did go down that road I wonder if we would be as satisfied with it as we are with the heavy gauge one? Decisions, decisions...
Randa