#1

Motorhomes towing cars. Why?

in Anything that's not Eriba-related. Sun Jun 29, 2014 6:39 pm
by Aaron Calder | 3.834 Posts

OK, I'll come clean. I just noticed that the last topic was number 999 so I couldn't resist ushering in the new millennium. Sincere thanks to all our contributors who have helped us reach this milestone.

Anyway, on our recent Norfolk jaunt I was once again surprised by the number of people on site with motorhomes some of which were ridiculously large in contrast to our bijou little Eribas and again I found myself wondering why anyone would pay out all that money for something the size of a small coach and then drag a car behind it on a trailer or A-frame so that they can explore the area once they are installed on a site? To my way of thinking, if they are going to tow a car, why don't they just tow a big caravan with a powerful car or 4WD?

Is it a macho thing on the lines of 'mine's bigger than yours', I wonder or is there a logic to the motorhome/car combination that I'm completely missing? As motorhome sales now exceed those of caravans and their owners usually have an everyday car as well there must be a good reason for this apparently bizarre choice.

Can anyone explain the logic to me as I am genuinely puzzled?

The other thing I found odd was the other motorhome owners (without a back-up vehicle) who waited outside the campsite in the rain looking miserable while waiting for a bus to take them out for the day.

Any comments, anyone?


Forum Administrator
2003 Triton 420 and Audi A4 2.0Tfsi S-line SE Cabriolet
Poptop320, and like this post!
Scroll up

#2

RE: Motorhomes towing cars. Why?

in Anything that's not Eriba-related. Sun Jun 29, 2014 7:36 pm
by Agger (deleted)
avatar

What I have noticed is more people driving or towing foreign vans, Burstner, Adria, Geist, Knaus etc even saw quite a rare Karmann on Damage Barton yesterday. A really nice guy and his wife pulled up next to me at Tintagel in a Burstner i890 elegance, biggest I've seen without slideouts! Really nice people no attitude etc just living it while they can and young enough to enjoy it



Last edited Sun Jun 29, 2014 7:36 pm | Scroll up

#3

RE: Motorhomes towing cars. Why?

in Anything that's not Eriba-related. Sun Jun 29, 2014 8:23 pm
by Poptop320 | 2.631 Posts

I'm with you with this one, why have two vehicles to MOT, insure, tax and maintain when you could just have one and a caravan.....


I like to pop my top when I go on holiday


Last edited Sun Jun 29, 2014 8:23 pm | Scroll up

#4

RE: Motorhomes towing cars. Why?

in Anything that's not Eriba-related. Mon Jun 30, 2014 7:08 am
by Deeps (deleted)
avatar

For two consequitive years - 2008 and 2009 - we rented Motorhomes for our extended tours of the Tuscany and Umbria regions of Italy. Advantages - a much higher level of comfort, water on tap during travelling without having to give a second thought to additional weight etc, no awning to erect to provide additional living space and finally, travel was much faster between overnight stops when compared to towing a caravan especially in hilly areas. Disadvantages - only one really and that is that we could have done with a car onboard for shopping and sightseeing for whilst it was possible with the Motorhome some of the area villages are quite small to negotiate.
The answer of course would have been a trailer with a small car attached which in fact is something we came across quite often. Unfortunately our finances do not run to this level of luxury especially when one takes into account servicing costs of two vehicles, taxes and insurances etc and last but no means least, where to park up the Motorhome off-season.
In all honesty though, were our financial situation to change as a result of a lottery win LOL then the Triton would be the first thing to go for whilst it provides us with good fun and we love it to bits, at the end of the day it only provides us with accommodation for a limited time of the year whilst a Motorhome would provide an extra dimension of comfort during that time. It would also be the case that we could use the Motorhome for a longer period during the year especially during the winter.
So yes, I'm all for these luxury Motorhomes dragging a trailer/car behind them if not actually in an enclosed onboard garage. If it's not going to leave you awake at night worrying how you're going to pay the darn thing off or how to meet the running costs then why not. Each to his/her own, we're only here the once so should make the most of it while we can.


2013 Triton 430, VW Touran TDI BM
мы прибываем невидимые - we arrive invisible

My You Tube Channel


Aaron Calder likes this post!
Last edited Mon Jun 30, 2014 7:09 am | Scroll up

#5

RE: Motorhomes towing cars. Why?

in Anything that's not Eriba-related. Mon Jun 30, 2014 9:32 am
by Aaron Calder | 3.834 Posts

Thanks for your detailed reply, Deeps. As I thought, there had to be good reasons why people go down the motorhome + car route even if I find the logic hard to understand.

One thing that always strikes me about these combinations though is their sheer impracticality in many areas of little, overcrowded Britain. I'd hate, for example, to try to negotiate the narrow lanes of Devon and Cornwall in one although I have to admit that drivers of articulated lorries and buses get them into some amazing places without apparent difficulty. I'm not that good a driver.

I suppose I've always associated camping and caravanning with a degree of 'making do' rather than luxury. What I like is the contrast with being at home with its hot water on tap, oven, freezer, microwave etc. If I wanted luxury on holiday then I'd fly to exotic locations, stay in the best hotels and be waited on. You could do a lot of that with the outlay for a massive motorhome and additional car. It's a bit like the demand for luxury camping holidays or 'glamping' as I think it is called. Where's the spirit of adventure in that?

Having said all that, I do occasionally find myself tempted by the latest wobbly white boxes with their luxurious appointments, fixed beds and space in which to move around and be comfortable. The problem is that on a site with a hundred or so 'ordinary' caravans and motorhomes, the Eriba will always stand out as being somehow special with its retro looks and minimalist equipment. That's what I fell in love with.

I'm not sure I understand your point about not being able to use the Eriba throughout the year. We've used our Triton in January in temperatures well below freezing and been very comfortable. With EHU and heating what's the problem?


Forum Administrator
2003 Triton 420 and Audi A4 2.0Tfsi S-line SE Cabriolet
Scroll up

#6

RE: Motorhomes towing cars. Why?

in Anything that's not Eriba-related. Mon Jun 30, 2014 9:58 am
by Frantone (deleted)
avatar

We have had motorhomes, a campervan and Eribas.
There are distinct differences, bonuses and difficulties with each and all, which suit personal choices and circumstances.
I find it very sad that in all 'camps' there are people who complain about the others and take up the 'us and them' stance.
This seems more common on motorhoming forums but is a growing theme in caravan circles.
TonyP


Troll & Galaxy.
Scroll up

#7

RE: Motorhomes towing cars. Why?

in Anything that's not Eriba-related. Mon Jun 30, 2014 10:09 am
by Deeps (deleted)
avatar

In some respects you answered your own question, Aaron, when asking "where's the spirit of adventure in that?" I wonder how many of us started off our camping lives under canvas before eventually moving up to a caravan or camper bus. Other than the two adventures in rented Motorhomes the wife and I have spent 100% of our time under canvas and it was only late last year that I decided enough was enough with this crawling in and out of bed located on the floor - time to enjoy a bit more luxury in our later years. Hence the Triton so in one respect we've moved up from camping to glamping or glamerous camping to give it it's full title. The point I was trying to establish in my earlier post was that, circumstances i.e. finances allowing, it wouldn't be a giant step up to running a Motorhome with accompanying car if possible. To the purists of course camping equates to sleeping under canvas and even using our little Eriba's is not considered to be real camping. It's all horses for courses I suppose.

Re the year round use of the Motorhome. Yes, I suppose in many respects I'm referring to where we live although of course the reasoning could easily apply to a much lesser extent in the UK. Over here we are obliged to mount winter tyres over the winter months something I don't believe they even produce for caravans although I could be wrong of course. But the point being, if the wife and I could afford to run a Motorhome with all that is involved then we could use it for winter trips to areas a bit further south of us, or even into Austria, for our annual skiing excursions thereby saving on hotel costs. Many do it and in fact winter camping using Motorhomes in areas that are deep in snow has become a bit of a fashion.


2013 Triton 430, VW Touran TDI BM
мы прибываем невидимые - we arrive invisible

My You Tube Channel


Aaron Calder likes this post!
Last edited Mon Jun 30, 2014 1:46 pm | Scroll up

#8

RE: Motorhomes towing cars. Why?

in Anything that's not Eriba-related. Mon Jun 30, 2014 10:23 am
by hampshireman (deleted)
avatar

We did see a very smart Morgan on a trailer yesterday and thought - yes, that's the sort of car you would have if into this way of touring.


My first railway painting and commission
Puck 225L pushing CMax 1.9TDI Ghia
Scroll up

#9

RE: Motorhomes towing cars. Why?

in Anything that's not Eriba-related. Mon Jun 30, 2014 11:59 am
by Aaron Calder | 3.834 Posts

Fair points, Deeps!

We too moved from VW camper (got too expensive to repair), then tent (great in warm, dry weather but misery in the wet and cold) to the Triton or 'tin tent' as I've heard them called, so to us having an Eriba is glamping.

Everything is a compromise so it's a case of horses for courses and over time our changing needs and finances will reflect this.

I wasn't aware of the motorhome v caravan animosity, Tony. As an Eriba owner I naturally feel superior to all of them.


Forum Administrator
2003 Triton 420 and Audi A4 2.0Tfsi S-line SE Cabriolet
likes this post!
Scroll up

#10

RE: Motorhomes towing cars. Why?

in Anything that's not Eriba-related. Mon Jun 30, 2014 1:47 pm
by Frantone (deleted)
avatar

Yes so do I!
It might not be animosity but there are often disparaging remarks made about 'tuggers and their antics' and the white box brigade, and similarly from the caravan side.
But you're quite right about feeling superior in an Eriba
I know of Eriba owners who, like me, say they can't stand caravans.

Which reminds me......I'm a bit sad that the Eriba name is now going to apply to all Hymer caravans. 😥

TonyP


Troll & Galaxy.
likes this post!
Scroll up

#11

RE: Motorhomes towing cars. Why?

in Anything that's not Eriba-related. Mon Jun 30, 2014 4:46 pm
by marmite | 405 Posts

When we moved up/down/sideways from canvas camping to an Eriba our oldest and most bonkers friend came up with

Caravamping - not quite a tent - not quite a caravan



Julie Grafo likes this post!
Last edited Mon Jun 30, 2014 4:46 pm | Scroll up

#12

RE: Motorhomes towing cars. Why?

in Anything that's not Eriba-related. Mon Jun 30, 2014 5:44 pm
by Randa france | 13.256 Posts

Zitat
Marmite:- CARAVAMPING


Just be careful you two that you're not invited out one night for a large Steak (Stake)


1999 Eriba Troll 530 pushing a VW Touran 2L TDi Match


Last edited Mon Jun 30, 2014 5:45 pm | Scroll up

#13

RE: Motorhomes towing cars. Why?

in Anything that's not Eriba-related. Mon Jun 30, 2014 6:53 pm
by marmite | 405 Posts

Fangs for the reminder


Scroll up

#14

RE: Motorhomes towing cars. Why?

in Anything that's not Eriba-related. Tue Jul 01, 2014 5:48 am
by ellen (deleted)
avatar

I've mentioned from time to time that we bought our Eriba to try out the touring world to see if we liked it, we did intend to buy a Hymer motorhome if touring was for us. We quickly fell in love with our little Eriba and would find it difficult to part with. Mind you we still wonder what touring with a motorhome will be like so we will eventually either hire a motorhome to try it or possibly buy one and try it, still keeping Doo-Dah of course. We really do need to satisfy our curiosity regarding a motorhome as we have been wondering how that life is for over 25yrs. I think we get best of all world's at the moment, our awning is more like a tent really as it's the kyham motordome so we feel like we are tenters that have a luxurious fixed bed to climb into. Ellen.


Proud owners of Doo-Dah our Familia 310
Scroll up

#15

RE: Motorhomes towing cars. Why?

in Anything that's not Eriba-related. Sun Jul 06, 2014 10:34 pm
by Skoderiba | 211 Posts

Coach and Porches.jpg - Bild entfernt (keine Rechte) At Holmsley, October 2011. The car on the trailer was a Porsche 911, with matching paint job.
The Eriba belonged to a taxi driver from Chichester.



Last edited Sun Jul 06, 2014 10:36 pm | Scroll up


Visitors
8 Members and 15 Guests are online.

Board Statistics
The forum has 12870 topics and 107939 posts.



disconnected Forum-Chat Members online 8