#16

RE: French sites

in Hi. Please take a couple of minutes to say hello here Sun Nov 20, 2016 5:54 pm
by eribanaut | 1.228 Posts

My point was that for towing stability, the nose weight needs to be as close as possible to the lower of the two quoted maximum figures for caravan and tow bar. If loaded correctly, occupying the caravan without the legs down must raise the noseweight above the recommended maximum figure.

But of course you are no longer towing it then, and you can drop the nose wheel to ease the load
Dave


Citroen C4 auto 1.6 Hdi Troll 552 - 2005
Scroll up

#17

RE: French sites

in Hi. Please take a couple of minutes to say hello here Sun Nov 20, 2016 9:46 pm
by Aaron Calder | 3.834 Posts

Quote: eribanaut wrote in post #16
But of course you are no longer towing it then, and you can drop the nose wheel to ease the load
Yes, of course, but that wasn't the point I was making.

I was questioning the suggestion that it is somehow illegal to put the corner steadies down even for a short time while parked at a French aire or lay-by. From the above posts it would appear that by putting the corner steadies down, this would give the gendarmes grounds to believe that the owner was intending to occupy the caravan contrary to some local ordinance rather than simply use it for half an hour to have meal, for example.

If this were the case (and assuming consistency of approach by Monsieur Plod), then having a lowered jockey wheel would also indicate intent to occupy and result in a similar outcome.

It just seems odd that bearing in mind how many of us on here regularly tour in France, this topic has never previously been raised.

I can't help thinking that the French police have better things to do with their time.


Forum Administrator
2003 Triton 420 and Audi A4 2.0Tfsi S-line SE Cabriolet
Pepé Le Pew and Bryn like this post!
Scroll up

#18

RE: French sites

in Hi. Please take a couple of minutes to say hello here Mon Nov 21, 2016 6:38 am
by Bryn | 1.027 Posts

I will ask at the Mairie today and see if there is any local laws, will post the response


Scroll up

#19

RE: French sites

in Hi. Please take a couple of minutes to say hello here Mon Nov 21, 2016 10:14 am
by eribanaut | 1.228 Posts

Although I played devils advocate I do agree with you, and in fact while never using an aire for overnight, have many times put the legs down to have a snack or drink both in France and Spain.
Dave


Citroen C4 auto 1.6 Hdi Troll 552 - 2005
Scroll up

#20

RE: French sites

in Hi. Please take a couple of minutes to say hello here Mon Nov 21, 2016 10:28 am
by Randa france | 13.258 Posts

We have nothing to add to this except to agree that we have never and wouldn't ever consider stopping overnight at an Aire.

This link doesn't throw much light on the matter but its interesting that they are talking only of Campervans (Motorhomes) and that reading between the lines the Brits are using the term Aire in its broadest sense. http://www.all-the-aires.com/

Zitat
The name Aires comes from the French 'Aire de Service Camping Car', their term for motorhome stopovers. British motorhomers and press refer to them as 'Aires', which technically just means 'area' in French. Therefore people have been confused with other signs using the word 'Aire' as it is commonly used on signs for motorway services and rest areas, children's play areas and activity areas to name a few.



Randa


1999 Eriba Troll 530 pushing a VW Touran 2L TDi Match
Scroll up

#21

RE: French sites

in Hi. Please take a couple of minutes to say hello here Tue Nov 22, 2016 7:47 am
by Islay Corbel (deleted)
avatar

Excuse me, Jobberwock


likes this post!
Scroll up

#22

RE: French sites

in Hi. Please take a couple of minutes to say hello here Tue Nov 22, 2016 10:28 am
by hampshireman (deleted)
avatar

We have never stopped overnight at aires and equally have never put the steadies down if parked for a toilet break or coffee stop. The Puck remains hitched.


Puck 225L pushing CMax 1.9TDI Ghia
Scroll up

#23

RE: French sites

in Hi. Please take a couple of minutes to say hello here Tue Nov 22, 2016 11:28 am
by Frantone (deleted)
avatar

We have stayed overnight on a couple of motorway aires. We only used the ones a good distance away from major cities or interchanges. I believe that the autoroute peage sections are safe to use at night because of their inherent unnatractiveness to thieves.




Troll gently nudging up against Galaxy.
Scroll up

#24

RE: French sites

in Hi. Please take a couple of minutes to say hello here Tue Nov 22, 2016 11:56 am
by jobberwock (deleted)
avatar

I've expressed my thoughts and what I hoped had been simple and helpful advice based on my extensive experiences of using these facilities the length and breadth of France and also limited but frequent use in Spain. If anyone should need further clarification then I would be happy to help and by all means PM me however as to a forum topic it seems as controversial as the application of laws in France itself and raises as many questions as answers.

Out of interest I 'googled' and from other forums found similar issues identified :

I was told early in my usage that
nothing on ground but tyres
The only restriction I have seen was a rather awkward policeman advising the next door MH that awning legs are not allowed to touch the ground
Several aires had signs forbidding camping i.e. no tables and chairs, awnings or steadies allowed on threat of punishment by the mayor (not sure if levelling blocks are allowed!).
Caravans using 'aires du campingcar' has been discussed on French forums & the concensus is that caravans can legally use aires provided nothing is placed on the ground, ie water carriers, steps etc. This is the letter of the law but in practise it probably would'nt matter.

now you can all argue that one out

we are using aires at the moment no problem yet, we was told don't unhook

French aire. ... If you do- stay hitched and dont put anything on the ground (legs, table or chairs ) ...

The definition of camping includes having nothing more than the vehicle wheels on the ground, so I guess a caravan with its steadies down is camping,

The Municipal laws that are generally used to enable aire de camping car being opened specifically exclude any form of camping in many cases,

that includes caravans, tents, trailer tents, awnings on camping cars, the use of rear steady legs by camping cars and even the placement and use of table and chairs as that is deemed camping. At La Alberca in Spain this year there is the usual notice about no steadies, tables chairs etc (are ramps allowed?) or you will be punished by the mayor.



Ian


Lovely 1997 Eriba 530GT
Randa france likes this post!
Scroll up

#25

RE: French sites

in Hi. Please take a couple of minutes to say hello here Tue Nov 22, 2016 7:50 pm
by hob (deleted)
avatar

It is plainly obvious that anyone entering a front or rear located door while hitched up will greatly exceed the noseweigt limits of both van and towing vehicle (specially if like me you weigh about 70 odd kilo's) or create a negative noseweight in the case of a rear door.

Therefore unless you rely on inbuilt safety margins (limits unknown) you need to do something to negate the strain on both towed and towing vehicles.

Either steadies or jockey wheel or a combination of both, also useful to lower the steadies while at a roadside service station while having dinner .... not easy to pinch it with all feet on the ground.


Forum moderator
Vauxhall Insignia Sri 1.8 petrol 2015 towing 2006 Triton 430 import
Scroll up

#26

RE: French sites

in Hi. Please take a couple of minutes to say hello here Tue Nov 22, 2016 7:56 pm
by Pepé Le Pew | 2.752 Posts

Quote: hob wrote in post #25
It is plainly obvious that anyone entering a front or rear located door while hitched up will greatly exceed the noseweigt limits of both van and towing vehicle (specially if like me you weigh about 70 odd kilo's) or create a negative noseweight in the case of a rear door.

Therefore unless you rely on inbuilt safety margins (limits unknown) you need to do something to negate the strain on both towed and towing vehicles.

Either steadies or jockey wheel or a combination of both, also useful to lower the steadies while at a roadside service station while having dinner .... not easy to pinch it with all feet on the ground.
Well said, Nev.

Except that instead of having dinner in the van at a service station, we'd have a sarni sitting in the car. The car's a much more comfortable place to sit

.


yy-R56kh
Aaron Calder likes this post!
Scroll up

#27

RE: French sites

in Hi. Please take a couple of minutes to say hello here Tue Nov 22, 2016 8:16 pm
by hob (deleted)
avatar

Quote: Pepé Le Pew wrote in post #26
Well said, Nev.

Except that instead of having dinner in the van at a service station, we'd have a sarni sitting in the car. The car's a much more comfortable place to sit

.


Or if like me you travel alone and eat in the services "feet down" and hitch lock on means its still there after you see the tea bag at the bottom of the cup.


Forum moderator
Vauxhall Insignia Sri 1.8 petrol 2015 towing 2006 Triton 430 import
Scroll up

#28

RE: French sites

in Hi. Please take a couple of minutes to say hello here Tue Nov 22, 2016 9:04 pm
by hob (deleted)
avatar

Ian, I have never towed in France so all my references apply to the UK however from reading the topic it seems a reputable campsite is the way to go.


Forum moderator
Vauxhall Insignia Sri 1.8 petrol 2015 towing 2006 Triton 430 import
Scroll up

#29

RE: French sites

in Hi. Please take a couple of minutes to say hello here Tue Nov 22, 2016 10:18 pm
by jobberwock (deleted)
avatar

Hob,
Please don't get the wrong impression from what I or others may have said or advised in using Aires in France.
They are in my experience a wonderful way of mixing and enjoying the French way of life. They are often in the heart
of a town/village/rural community. You will be shopping in the french shops or markets, drinking in the bars,enjoying meals,
watching boules and overall having a very relaxing and carefree time. We love the river and canal walks that stretch for miles.
We don't tend to spend a great deal of time actually in or around the caravan unless the weather is poor.

Having the legs/steadies up, having been advised, and whilst parked up has not been a problem for us when it felt prudent to be careful.

As for fear of crime ....I'd feel less safe in th UK these days !

As for the gendarmes...well they do look scary...but perhaps I have a guilty conscience

Ian

PS...Just remembered. We never travel during school/holiday periods.


Lovely 1997 Eriba 530GT


Last edited Tue Nov 22, 2016 10:30 pm | Scroll up

#30

RE: French sites

in Hi. Please take a couple of minutes to say hello here Wed Nov 23, 2016 8:51 am
by Lily (deleted)
avatar

Well thank you all so far for the useful info. Just one last question. I hear that it's dangerous to stay over night on the Aires on motorways? any comments anyone? Of course we would not unhitch. We would only unhitch at a campsite.
Thank you again.


likes this post!
Scroll up


Visitors
2 Members and 92 Guests are online.

Board Statistics
The forum has 12871 topics and 107944 posts.



disconnected Forum-Chat Members online 2