Could this be the end of camping as we know it?
Could this be the end of camping as we know it?
in Anything that's not Eriba-related. Wed Sep 26, 2018 6:23 pmby Aaron Calder • | 3.834 Posts
I read somewhere that motorhome sales now outstrip caravan sales in the UK and from my own experience, this would also appear to be true in France.
On our current holiday I have remarked upon the number of motorhomes parked in car parks or on special 'aires', often crammed in cheek by jowl like gypsy encampments. Why anyone would want to camp like that is beyond me as the owners of these very expensive vehicles are clearly not without a bob or two to pay site fees.
These places come to mind:
1. Lac d'Orient, Troyes - loads of motorhomes overnighting all along the lake front.
2. La Palmyre (near St Palais-sur-Mer) - motorhomes parked nose to tail along the roadside backing onto the beaches and crammed into the car park (see below), A chap on our campsite was furious about this and said that if you go into the woods near where these vans park, you are hit by the smell of sewage from where they have dumped the contents of their chemical toilets.
StPalais08.jpg - Bild entfernt (keine Rechte)
3. Blaye, (near the Citadel) - when I tried to get a picture showing the sheer size of the Citadel I couldn't due to the massed ranks of freeloading motorhomers on the adjacent aire, (see below)
Blaye29.jpg - Bild entfernt (keine Rechte)
4. Forges-les-Eaux - usually, if you arrive early at a site, you expect it to fill up gradually as other people arrive. This site didn't. It was when I was emptying the toilet at the vidoir that I noticed maybe thirty or so motorhomes all parked directly opposite the site entrance. On further investigation this turned out to be a council-provided aire for camping cars. No wonder the campsite was so quiet.
These are just a few examples; I'm sure you have more. The point that occurred to me was that if, due to the increasing use of motorhomes and decline of caravans, linked with the increasing availability of 'aires', caravan site incomes may well fall to the point where they are no longer viable forcing them to close.
Another possible outcome could be a further proliferation of statics (chalets, lodges, glam camps etc) as site owners seek alternative revenue streams with a consequent decline in the availability of touring pitches for caravanners to use.
It's just a thought but I wondered if anyone else had given this any consideration?
Forum Administrator
2003 Triton 420 and Audi A4 2.0Tfsi S-line SE Cabriolet
RE: Could this be the end of camping as we know it?
in Anything that's not Eriba-related. Wed Sep 26, 2018 6:27 pmby rambling robin (deleted)
It’s a fad Once they find out how inflexible they are they will all get caravans instead😀
Neurotic Kia Sportage trundling MegaPuck 410
RE: Could this be the end of camping as we know it?
in Anything that's not Eriba-related. Wed Sep 26, 2018 7:20 pmby Randa france • | 13.258 Posts
I'm sure many folk were just waiting for me to tick the "Likes" box.
Also it wouldn't surprise you to read that I totally agree with Brian's sentiments. We have seen the same goings on for a few years now and last year at Brussels we had a lively conversation with a campsite owner who was fed up to the teeth with them.
Their attitude towards him and his campsite was to turn up as late as possible for one night, use his facilities to dump their waste and top up their water tanks before leaving the following morning as early as possible, some to park in his outside car park that he shares with a local municipal swimming pool, before getting the bus into the city for the day, only to move on elsewhere late afternoon.
Again this year, we noticed that there was a campervan parked in a carpark outside the municipal campsite at Montbard, the occupants of which we were sure were using the campsite facilities. A 15 Euro a night campsite. Another example of a lovely well run family campsite is at St Cirq Lapopie, 17 euros a night yet the local authorites have opened a campervan site just outside the perimeter. However they are asked to pay 7 euros a night plus 2 euros each per shower. Any number of vans were using it but why? Great for us but to slum it to save 5 euros a night?
Both Northern Brittany and many spots in Ireland are now trying to stop them from carpark camping by putting 2 metre gantry barriers up.
There are some large van owners who do abide by the age old rules of camping and bought their vans thinking that they would be easier to use than tents/caravans before realising that they have some serious drawbacks, the main one being the lack of mobility once on a campsite. We've talked to quite a few this year who were a little envious of our Eriba.
Randa
ERIBAFOLK POP UP EVERYWHERE 1999 Eriba Troll 530 pushing a VW Touran 2L TDi Match
RE: Could this be the end of camping as we know it?
in Anything that's not Eriba-related. Wed Sep 26, 2018 7:35 pmby eribaMotters • | 5.588 Posts
I think the bias towards motor homes is on the increase but another element needs to be taken into consideration. That is out of season holidays.
In 2017 we had the opportunity to holiday out of the main summer season for the first time. We spent the month of September in France and one of the first things we noticed was the more mature person in a motorhome. In late June/early July this year we noticed exactly the same thing.
Colin
Skoda Yeti diesel 2wd _ ex 430, 552, camplet trailer tent, 310, now a nice white 2017 430.
RE: Could this be the end of camping as we know it?
in Anything that's not Eriba-related. Wed Sep 26, 2018 9:36 pmby Julie Grafo • | 3.555 Posts
Motorhomes do seem to be on the increase in some places although in central Spain this year it was still mostly caravans. It is unfair to tar them all with the same brush. Our neighbours have a nice new motorhome this year now they have retired but previous to this they have converted 3 old Transit type vans into campers to take their kids away. They are equally horrified at the people they see who in their view don't understand the ethics or niceties of camping. Hopefully we will educate these motorhomers or they will decide to do the sensible thing and get an Eriba. Not holding my breath.
Julie & Neil. 2008 530GT pushing Honda CR-V 1.6 iDTEC SE+
RE: Could this be the end of camping as we know it?
in Anything that's not Eriba-related. Wed Sep 26, 2018 10:27 pmby steamdrivenandy (deleted)
OK, I've gone through 5m hightop Transit PVC, 6m Adria coachbuilt, two Troll 540's, two WWB's and I've arrived back at a 5.2m hightop Transit of the same type as we started with.
I love Eriba Tourings but I don't really enjoy all the faffing about that caravans entail. By the same token coachbuilt motorhomes are all very nice but just too big for use as a daily driver.
I'm happy with 4 belted seats that make up into 7ft long single beds, a fridge, a sink, gas hobs, a proper toilet, masses of worktop , loads of lockers and a hurt great 3ft deep full width 'boot' for the dog crate and all the other stuff.
We always use formal sites, can't see the point of off grid pitching and enjoy our site showers as we don't have one on board.
Sadly too many folk are taken in by the image of campervan living but don't realise that in pitching in car parks etc they're actually destroying the thing that they purchased the van to enjoy.
Middlesex 29 years
Hertfordshire 15 years
Essex 2 years
North Yorkshire 15 years
North Staffordshire 9 years
'Eribacar' - aka Horizons Unlimited Innovation 3 MWB Ford Transit panel van conversion.
RE: Could this be the end of camping as we know it?
in Anything that's not Eriba-related. Wed Sep 26, 2018 10:41 pmby steamdrivenandy (deleted)
Just to extend my last post.
Having a 5.2m PVC is akin to white van man and they get everywhere. Well everywhere without a height restriction anyway. We no longer run two cars and I'll use the family Yeti whilst at home, unless Mrs SDA needs it, when I'll use the Tranny if I need to go out.
We save on caravan insurance, caravan storage and can be packed for a break in an hour. True we have to break camp every day we want to go off somewhere but you set your camp up so that it isn't a big issue. I've loved getting rid of Wastemaster, Aquaroll, awning, noseweight gauge and enjoyed the challenge of minimilisation, determined not to get swamped with stuff.
Middlesex 29 years
Hertfordshire 15 years
Essex 2 years
North Yorkshire 15 years
North Staffordshire 9 years
'Eribacar' - aka Horizons Unlimited Innovation 3 MWB Ford Transit panel van conversion.
RE: Could this be the end of camping as we know it?
in Anything that's not Eriba-related. Thu Sep 27, 2018 3:26 amby Blueyonder (deleted)
I think that many expensive motor homes are bought with the lump sum payments on retirement. We have come across lots of EU civil servants and public sector retirees who bought with their golden handshakes. Pension benefits like these are diminishing, so maybe motorhome sales will too. I have nothing against motor homes, but I will never understand why they squeeze themselves on cheap aires or think they can ignore ‘no motorhome’ signs and go wherever they like, often causing chaos for others.
We are currently touring Canada and the US for 5 weeks. Even though the rigs here are enormous, they are far less of an impact generally than those in Europe.
2017 Land Rover Discovery Sport HSE pulling a silver 2018 Troll 535 GT
RE: Could this be the end of camping as we know it?
in Anything that's not Eriba-related. Thu Sep 27, 2018 7:15 amby steamdrivenandy (deleted)
It's also true that renting a motorhome has become much more popular than a few years back. Sometimes these are vans owned privately with the rental facilitated by an agency, making use of the downtime when the van would not be being used by the owner. Though there are obvious risks in letting someone else use your van. Others are owned by rental companies, but only a few are sign written as renters don't like it and it reduces residual value when the van is sold on. It's expensive to rent a van butnot anywhere near as expensive as fully owning one and having it sit on the drive for 45 weeks a year.
Like my Eribas, I regard mine as my hobby which I'm gradually bringing back to original condition, almost as a homage to the original Innovation we purchased new in 2006.
Middlesex 29 years
Hertfordshire 15 years
Essex 2 years
North Yorkshire 15 years
North Staffordshire 9 years
'Eribacar' - aka Horizons Unlimited Innovation 3 MWB Ford Transit panel van conversion.
RE: Could this be the end of camping as we know it?
in Anything that's not Eriba-related. Thu Sep 27, 2018 7:36 amby cabbie37 • | 695 Posts
I may have got the wrong end of the stick on this, but I think related to this theme is the decline in the typical 'Municipal' campsite. The impression I have gained is that some years ago, the French government started an initiative to 'uprate' the facilities offered by such places. Hence, you see chalets and facilities for motorhomes more commonly now. Many of the Municipals simply weren't able to afford the improvements and simply closed, much to my disappointment... I've just come back from Brittany and the last campsite, just on the outskirts of St. Malo, is now about 50% chalets, each chalet simply dropped onto what used to be an emplacement. That appeas increasingly common...
Lets's face it, everything is in constant change and the changing nature of camping is no exception. When I started camping, I had a heavy canvas tent and a motor home would have been a home converted van. It is clear to me, that over the past few years, Motorhoming has seen a huge increase. I don't know what that reflects, perhaps just a greater disposable income by a larger percentage of the population.
MInd you, even I muttered under my breath when at an earlier pitch on the Brittany trip, the world went dark when a Motorhome built on a 7 tonne Mercedes truck chassis pitched next to me for the night...
RE: Could this be the end of camping as we know it?
in Anything that's not Eriba-related. Thu Sep 27, 2018 9:25 amby eribanaut • | 1.228 Posts
Just had a quick look around the small site we are on in Slovenia, 14 camper vans [all small], 5 tents [young people] 2 cars with sleeping on top, 1 touring caravan [us].
Dave
Skoda Kodiaq 2.0 150 Tdi DSG Troll 552 - 2005
Don't worry about the destination, enjoy the journey.
RE: Could this be the end of camping as we know it?
in Anything that's not Eriba-related. Fri Sep 28, 2018 1:08 amby gattim (deleted)
I suspect two further reasons might well be:
1) Macho man “Look at me I’m driving a big lorry!”
2) Too frightened/worried/timid to tow
Just as Blueyonder suggested we once met a couple marooned on a French campsite in a brand new enormous motorhome they had bought with their retirement lump sum. The local supermarket had a height restriction on the car park so they were forced to buy everything from the camp shop and basically stay on site 24/7.
The thing was so massive you could probably have declared it a separate country
RE: Could this be the end of camping as we know it?
in Anything that's not Eriba-related. Fri Sep 28, 2018 7:35 amby Islay Corbel (deleted)
I dont know what it's like in Britain or other European countries, only home. They're a plague. Some towns here have banned them as already, traffic is difficult. In Binic, theres a park especially for them, but it's cunningly hidden down a side road, away from the beaches........if they want a view, they have to pay. Quite rightly so in my humble opinion.
But, I do understand. Often, out of season, we find ourselves the only people with our own teeth on the site. They must buy them with the kid's inheritance......many very modest people are driving around in enormous campervans. But, isn't it better when you're too old to be pushing a caravan about, to be having fun with your mates....rather then be alone at home. They get up late, fish a bit, have an aperitif, lunch, snooze, petanque, aperitif, dinner......nice life!
What I don't understand is how They park 5 centimetres from each other, in overcrowded car parks without a blade of grass.....they must hear each other snoring and farting.....ghastly.
I think municipal camping are thriving in France....Hugh I think you liked the one here! They are often cleaner than some private ones we've stayed at. Atbthe one in Clisson, the lady in charge reckons thatbcaravans are be coming more popular again. We have noticed a lot more teeny, old ones about.
« Sidney Powell responds after Trump campaign says she is not part of legal team: | Best way to insure my Eriba? » |
Visitors
5 Members and 374 Guests are online. |
Board Statistics
The forum has 12872
topics
and
107953
posts.
|