#1

Pop top catches

in Improving your pride and joy and how to fix things Mon Mar 19, 2018 4:02 pm
by chezmart | 186 Posts

Returning home today from our weekend away we were flagged down because our roof had popped open at the front.
I thought this was strange as I definitely remember fastening it.
Luckily I managed to pull into a services almost immediately but when I went into the van to check, the front catches had snapped. As a temporary fix I thought if I turn the hooks round and attach it with the finger pull part it might hold at a slower speed. This failed almost immediately and the roof popped again. We managed to get off the dual carriageway and put the roof down again but now there was no way to hold the roof down!
We limped home at 20-30 mph but the roof still came up several times at this speed.
Has anyone else come across this before?
I'm wondering if the plastic has become brittle over the winter.
AL have quoted £65 each which seems extortionate for such a small part.
Jandi think they are about £35 each but will let me know an exact price when they contact Hymer.
Neither have ever heard of these breaking before.


2012 Troll 550 - BMW 220d Cabriolet
Scroll up

#2

RE: Pop top catches

in Improving your pride and joy and how to fix things Mon Mar 19, 2018 4:07 pm
by steamdrivenandy (deleted)
avatar

We've had Eribas up to 11 years old and not seen a sign of the roof hooks being damaged or stressed.


'I've got nothing to do on this hot afternoon
but to settle down and write you a line.'


2012 Bailey Pegasus 2 Rimini being dragged by nothing at all


Last edited Mon Mar 19, 2018 4:07 pm | Scroll up

#3

RE: Pop top catches

in Improving your pride and joy and how to fix things Mon Mar 19, 2018 4:11 pm
by eribaMotters | 5.600 Posts

Daft question, but have you been putting the rear of the roof down before the front.
On collection of our new shape van Lowdhams drew my attention thst it had to be done in this order unlike the pre 2009/10 vans where the order was not important.
Failure to do so would mean the pop top would not sit correctly.

Colin


Skoda Yeti diesel 2wd _ ex 430, 552, camplet trailer tent, 310, now a nice white 2017 430.
Scroll up

#4

RE: Pop top catches

in Improving your pride and joy and how to fix things Mon Mar 19, 2018 4:17 pm
by chezmart | 186 Posts

Quote: eribaMotters wrote in post #3
Daft question, but have you been putting the rear of the roof down before the front.
On collection of our new shape van Lowdhams drew my attention thst it had to be done in this order unlike the pre 2009/10 vans where the order was not important.
Failure to do so would mean the pop top would not sit correctly.

Colin


I always pull the back down first as I've heard about this issue before. I also never hook the catches until the whole roof is lowered.
To be honest I was amazed at how slow a speed the roof would lift up when trying to crawl home. It would lift at 25mph so i can imagine the force at 60mph on the catches would be huge.


2012 Troll 550 - BMW 220d Cabriolet
Scroll up

#5

RE: Pop top catches

in Improving your pride and joy and how to fix things Mon Mar 19, 2018 4:31 pm
by steamdrivenandy (deleted)
avatar

I'm not sure how much would be aerodynamic lift that would create more lift the faster you went and how much is just the joggling of the road surface and upward spring pressure.


'I've got nothing to do on this hot afternoon
but to settle down and write you a line.'


2012 Bailey Pegasus 2 Rimini being dragged by nothing at all
Scroll up

#6

RE: Pop top catches

in Improving your pride and joy and how to fix things Tue Mar 20, 2018 8:54 am
by Islay Corbel (deleted)
avatar

Parked up, the wind can push the roof up. You dont need to be moving. Our caravan is 21 this year with original catches . Yikes!


Scroll up

#7

RE: Pop top catches

in Improving your pride and joy and how to fix things Tue Mar 20, 2018 9:18 am
by Pepé Le Pew | 2.752 Posts

Quote: chezmart wrote in post #1

AL have quoted £65 each which seems extortionate for such a small part.
Jandi think they are about £35 each but will let me know an exact price when they contact Hymer.
Neither have ever heard of these breaking before.
Martin

It might be worth having a look at this. The entry for Wednesday the 17th of January.

The person at AL who told you they'd never heard of this before - and who quoted you sixty-five quid - has obviously forgotten about the people who wrote the blog and who got a quote from AL a few weeks ago for less than £40.

If it was me I think I might ask them to double-check the price.

Jandi's quote seems much more... erm... honest.

.


chezmart likes this post!
Scroll up

#8

RE: Pop top catches

in Improving your pride and joy and how to fix things Tue Mar 20, 2018 10:11 am
by chezmart | 186 Posts

Thanks Pete. Interesting blog.
The catches shown were the rear catches. The front catches on vans after 2010 have a threaded insert and a lock nut on them so I guess this is why I was quoted more. The mark up on these spare parts must be huge.


2012 Troll 550 - BMW 220d Cabriolet
Scroll up

#9

RE: Pop top catches

in Improving your pride and joy and how to fix things Tue Mar 20, 2018 10:14 am
by steamdrivenandy (deleted)

'I've got nothing to do on this hot afternoon
but to settle down and write you a line.'


2012 Bailey Pegasus 2 Rimini being dragged by nothing at all
Scroll up

#10

RE: Pop top catches

in Improving your pride and joy and how to fix things Tue Mar 20, 2018 10:15 am
by Pepé Le Pew | 2.752 Posts

Quote: chezmart wrote in post #8
Thanks Pete. Interesting blog.
The catches shown were the rear catches. The front catches on vans after 2010 have a threaded insert and a lock nut on them so I guess this is why I was quoted more. The mark up on these spare parts must be huge.
Sorry Martin - I didn't realise there was a difference between the front catches and the rear ones.

And I agree about the huge mark up on parts. Definitely huger at some places than others.

No names, no pack drill...

.


chezmart likes this post!
Scroll up

#11

RE: Pop top catches

in Improving your pride and joy and how to fix things Tue Mar 20, 2018 10:15 am
by chezmart | 186 Posts

SDA
Thanks but it's a different catch on the newer vans. They have a threaded insert and lock nut.


2012 Troll 550 - BMW 220d Cabriolet


Last edited Tue Mar 20, 2018 10:16 am | Scroll up

#12

RE: Pop top catches

in Improving your pride and joy and how to fix things Tue Mar 20, 2018 10:17 am
by Pepé Le Pew | 2.752 Posts

Quote: chezmart wrote in post #11
Thanks but it's a different catch on the newer vans. They have a threaded insert and lock nut.
How old is the van in the blog then? I thought it was a relatively recent one.

.


Scroll up

#13

RE: Pop top catches

in Improving your pride and joy and how to fix things Tue Mar 20, 2018 10:18 am
by chezmart | 186 Posts

Yes it's a newish van but it was a rear catch in the blog that broke.


2012 Troll 550 - BMW 220d Cabriolet
Scroll up

#14

RE: Pop top catches

in Improving your pride and joy and how to fix things Tue Mar 20, 2018 10:21 am
by Pepé Le Pew | 2.752 Posts

Quote: chezmart wrote in post #13
Yes it's a newish van but it was a rear catch in the blog that broke.
Ah.

Just forget anything I put.

I was in the middle of crocheting an egg cosy. Best I get back to it, I reckon.

.


Eribanut likes this post!
Scroll up

#15

RE: Pop top catches

in Improving your pride and joy and how to fix things Tue Mar 20, 2018 10:25 am
by chezmart | 186 Posts

Quote: Pepé Le Pew wrote in post #14
Quote: chezmart wrote in post #13
Yes it's a newish van but it was a rear catch in the blog that broke.
Ah.

Just forget anything I put.

I was in the middle of crocheting an egg cosy. Best I get back to it, I reckon.

.



Thanks Pete. The message you replied to was a reply to SDA. No offence meant


2012 Troll 550 - BMW 220d Cabriolet
Scroll up


Visitors
3 Members and 139 Guests are online.

Board Statistics
The forum has 12890 topics and 108059 posts.



disconnected Forum-Chat Members online 3